Mona Cunningham doesn't believe in marriage, but she doesn't want to lose a good man, so she accepts William Lincoln's proposal. But with dark secrets from her past hanging over her, each time the wedding date nears Mona finds some reason to postpone.

William is increasingly frustrated. How many times can one woman reschedule a wedding? So when his first love, Katherine Clinton, e-mails him in hopes of reconnecting, William agrees to meet. Their reunion is so intense that now William is the one postponing the wedding so he can figure out a way to be with his true love. William devises a plan that will spare him having to hurt either woman. But when the scheme goes awry and the truth comes out, all three lives will be forever changed.