Everyone in Bedford Falls wants to see Robbie Masters settled down and happy, but Robbie knows love comes with a price, and it's not one he wants to pay. He can't trust his heart to make a sound investment.

But then he meets self-help goddess Sara Wright. Sara's quirky humor and sweet wisdom light Robbie's soul and rekindle his passions, and for the first time in his life he wonders if Happily Ever After isn't more than a distant dream.